← All insights

Essay

How to know a promise was kept: ask the person you promised

Status comes from the people doing the work. Proof comes from the people who were promised. Why the follow-up question matters more than the report.

Most businesses measure delivery from the inside. The team says it’s done, the job gets closed, and the report shows green.

There’s a simpler test, and it’s usually skipped: ask the person you promised.

What the research says

Customers mostly don’t speak up. In a 2025 survey of 20,001 consumers in 14 countries, including the US, only 29% sent feedback to the company after a bad experience. 30% told no one at all, the highest share since the study started in 2021. And for every 10 bad experiences, 5 led people to spend less or stop buying (Qualtrics XM Institute, 2026 Consumer Experience Trends Report).

Who’s saying it: Qualtrics sells customer-feedback software, so it has a reason to say feedback is getting harder to collect. It’s a big consumer survey across many industries, not trades in particular. For a service business the point still holds: if you wait for the customer to tell you, most won’t. You have to ask.

An older study points the same way. In 2004, a study of more than 11,000 managers found that those who followed up with the people around them showed striking improvement, and those who didn’t barely beat random chance (Goldsmith and Morgan, strategy+business). Both authors are executive coaches, so follow-up is their business.

Status is not proof

When a team member says “it’s done”, they’re telling you what they believe. That’s valuable. It isn’t the same as the customer, the builder or the GC who relied on the promise saying “yes, that’s what we agreed.”

The gap between those two is where most complaints are born. The work was done, but not quite the way the other person expected, and nobody asked until they called.

What to put in place

  1. Name the person who was promised. Every commitment has one. Write their name next to it.
  2. Agree the question in advance. “When this is done, we’ll check with you that it matches what we agreed.”
  3. Ask when it closes. A short message or a two-minute call: “Was this done the way we agreed?”
  4. Record the answer. Yes, no or partly. That record is your evidence, and over time it shows where promises drift.
  5. Follow up on the nos. A “no” answered quickly often builds more trust than a “yes” nobody asked for.

In the ERMODA Check this is the A · Assured step: the promise isn’t closed until the person who depends on it has been told and has confirmed.

Your move

If you run your own business: for the next ten jobs you finish, ask each customer that one question and note the answers.

If you have an office team or a service manager: add “confirmed by the customer” to every job that matters, and look at the ones missing it each Monday.

Want to see where your promises drift? Try the 30-minute promise self-check, or Ask ERMODA.

Questions

Why not just trust the status report?

A closed job tells you what the team believes. It can be right and still miss what the customer expected. Asking closes that gap.

How often should we ask?

When each job closes. A two-minute call or a short message the next day is enough. For plan customers, ask after each visit.